
Ellis Island Hotel
Best for straightforward, budget‑minded stays near the Strip with affordable on-site dining and free parking.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Ellis Island Hotel, Casino & Brewery is an off-Strip, family-friendly property with casual dining, a single seasonal pool and free self-parking — good for travelers who want a local, budget-conscious base near the Strip. New York-New York Hotel & Casino is a themed 4-star Strip resort with a recognizable skyline, roller coaster and a large casino — a better fit for visitors who want a full-service Strip resort experience with lots of food and entertainment options.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for straightforward, budget‑minded stays near the Strip with affordable on-site dining and free parking.

Best for visitors who want a classic themed Strip resort with many restaurants, a large casino and visible Strip presence.
When Ellis Island wins: pick Ellis Island if you want an all-ages, lower‑cost option with easy, free self-parking, a casual brewpub (The Front Yard) and a compact hotel footprint for simple, convenient stays just off the Strip.
When New York-New York wins: choose New York-New York if you want to stay on the Strip in a larger resort with many restaurant choices, a fuller conference and entertainment program, and the visual landmark of the skyline and roller coaster.
Bottom line: Ellis Island is a practical, local favorite that keeps costs and fuss low; New York-New York is a bigger, themed Strip resort that offers more dining, gaming and resort-style options if you want the Strip scene.
| Category | Ellis Island Hotel | New York-New York Hotel & Casino |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Local, casual casino hotel and brewery | Themed, higher‑energy Strip resort |
| Location | One block east of the Las Vegas Strip (4250 Koval Lane) | On the Las Vegas Strip (3790 Las Vegas Blvd S) |
| Size | 288 rooms and suites (family-owned property) | Large resort (2024 rooms listed in supplier data) |
| Audience / age policy | Family-friendly; children welcome (primary guest usually must be 21) | All ages welcome (minimum check-in age listed as 21 on supplier policies) |
| Pools & hot tubs | One outdoor seasonal heated pool + adjoining hot tub; cabanas and loungers | Outdoor seasonal pool(s) and a hot tub listed in supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Five casual outlets (The Front Yard, Village Pub & Café, Ellis Island BBQ, Metro Pizza, Via Focaccia) focused on affordable American/Italian/BBQ fare | Many outlets (supplier lists 17 restaurants and 9 bars/lounges; includes Gallagher's Steakhouse and 24‑hour room service) |
| Spa & wellness | No standalone treatment spa found; hot tub only | Full spa details not published in supplier data |
| Casino | 10,506 sq ft casino with 262 slot machines, 8 gaming tables and a VIP room | Large casino floor (84,000 sq ft) with ~900 slot machines, ~80 gaming tables and VIP gaming rooms |
| Parking | Free self-parking, including RV/bus/truck parking | Covered self-parking and valet available for a surcharge |
| Event & meeting space | Several small-to-mid event venues (largest 350 capacity) and one 665 sq ft meeting room | Extensive meeting space (21 meeting rooms; ~21,000 sq ft of conference space) |
Ellis Island sits one block east of the Strip on Koval Lane, within walking distance to many Strip attractions.
Choose Ellis Island for a quieter, slightly removed base with easy Strip access.
New York-New York sits on the Las Vegas Strip and is visible as a themed skyline with an on-site coaster.
Choose New York-New York for direct Strip access and the classic themed-resort atmosphere.
Ellis Island keeps room types simple and focused on comfortable, straightforward accommodations.
Ellis Island fits travelers who want simple, functional rooms near the Strip.
New York-New York offers a wide range of room types across a large resort footprint.
Pick New York-New York if you want more room choices and on-site resort services.
Ellis Island’s restaurants focus on casual, affordable American and Italian food plus a brewpub.
Ellis Island is best for budget-conscious, casual dining with a brewpub feel.
New York-New York lists many restaurants and bars to cover a broad range of dining needs.
New York-New York is better if you want many on-site dining choices and late-night options.
Ellis Island has a single outdoor seasonal heated pool plus an adjoining hot tub reserved for guests.
Ellis Island’s pool is small and quiet — suited to relaxing between Strip outings.
New York-New York offers outdoor seasonal pool access and other resort recreation tied to a bigger Strip property.
New York-New York provides typical Strip resort pool options alongside larger entertainment.
Ellis Island’s wellness and nightlife are modest and locally focused.
Ellis Island suits travelers who want low-key nightlife and a simple place to relax.
New York-New York provides a broader range of entertainment and likely more wellness options than a small off‑Strip property.
New York-New York is for travelers who want more nightlife and resort-style entertainment options.

Ellis Island — free self-parking, affordable dining and a straightforward room mix make it a budget-friendly choice near the Strip.

New York-New York — themed skyline, roller coaster and many restaurants put you in the middle of the Strip scene.

New York-New York — supplier listing notes 17 restaurants and 9 bars/lounges for wider culinary options.

Ellis Island — on-site brewpub (The Front Yard), karaoke lounge and casino bar offer local, easygoing entertainment.
New York-New York sits directly on the Las Vegas Strip; Ellis Island is one block east of the Strip (about a 10–15 minute walk to main Strip areas).
New York-New York has many more on-site outlets (supplier lists 17 restaurants and 9 bars); Ellis Island offers five casual restaurants and bars.
Yes — Ellis Island is family-friendly and welcomes children of all ages; the primary guest checking in is generally expected to be 21.
Supplier information does not publish a named full-service spa; spa details are not published in the supplied listing and should be confirmed with the property.
Explore how Ellis Island Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·